www.phetasy.com, Matt Taibbi is a journalist and author. On December 31, 2021, The Joe Rogan Experience podcast on Spotify posted an episode with an interview with physician Dr. Robert Malone full of misinformation about the Covid-19 vaccine. Gee, have political leaders ever actually lied? As then-chief medical officer for a Florida pharmaceutical company called Alchem Laboratories Corp., he was involved during the early stages of the coronavirus pandemic in research looking into Pepcid, the heartburn medicine, as a potential COVID-19 treatment. It wasn't the first time Rogan or his guests have floated dubious or outright false information about the pandemic. A massive rock formation? Malone made baseless and disproven claims, including falsely stating that getting vaccinated puts people who already have had COVID-19 at higher risk. has issued guidelines on certifying deaths that detail how to track the immediate cause of death, an underlying cause or a significant condition that contributed to the death. Rogan did not respond to NPR's request for comment. 0. While audio apps so far have escaped the scrutiny that has befallen social media platforms such as Facebook and Twitter, the pressure on Spotify illustrates how podcasts have emerged as an influential source of misinformation. Not understanding these facts would indeed be losing touch with reality. But audio can be a powerful way to spread misinformation because of all the qualities that make the format so compelling to listeners, said Valerie Wirtschafter, a senior data analyst at the Brookings Institution. The conversation included a false equivalence between the vaccine and Nazi medical experiments, baseless conjecture that President Biden is not actually vaccinated and inaccurate interpretations of government data and guidelines. We have an infodemic going on that is prolonging the pandemic and it is causing people to make bad choices and actually die. I dont know if this guy is right or wrong. Dr. Robert Malone, Inventor of using "RNA as a drug" and core mRNA and DNA. But it has been reluctant to take action against Rogans podcast, which reaches an estimated 11 million people per episode; nor does it include a warning label regarding potential misinformation on any podcast episodes. Malones rise to right-wing stardom and subsequent fall into social media purgatory underscore how accomplished doctors can exploit their credentials to spread harmful misinformation. And many of the spreaders have been anonymous social media accounts posting misinformation like graffiti on a bathroom stall. (This is missing key context.) . A few weeks ago, her followers started sending her a link to an episode of the Joe Rogan Experience, the most popular podcast in the world. Actually, on the podcast, Malone seemed to suggest that it was the pandemic and that the leaders have been the ones advocating for use of the Covid-19 vaccines. Dr. Malones suggestion that Mr. Biden urged Prime Minister Narendra Modi of India to conceal the successful use of the drug ivermectin in Uttar Pradesh, the countrys most populous state, does not add up. "It provides a sense of false balance, like there's two sides to the scientific evidence when, really, there is not. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices. Or make that had. Were not focused on something as small as just one episode or Rogan. He said a state in India, Uttar Pradesh, "crushed COVID" using an early treatment package featuring ivermectin but resolved with the U.S. not to disclose that. When we stray away from our core principles of freedom of speech, freedom of expression, and freedom of debate, democracy is lost. http://www.instagram.com/punkiejohnson, Krystal Ball and Saagar Enjeti are political commentators and hosts of the YouTube show and podcast "Breaking Points." positive, theyre determined to have died from Covid. Dr. Malone. Rep. Has that ever happened in the U.S.? This is what really bothers me, she tells, ny podcast that platforms dangerous people, people spreading dangerous ideas and misinformation, should not be allowed to go unchecked on the Spotify platform, says Abbie Richards, a researcher specializing in misinformation. 2023 www.statesman.com. Hammer, break it down. (It does not.) Richards gave Rein the idea of penning an open letter to Spotify when he approached her with his concerns over the Malone episode. Yet Rivera believes Spotify has an enormous ethical obligation to do so. Fact-check:No, the government isn't monitoring SMS texts for COVID misinformation. For example, it would be a bit too outrageous to claim that squirrels control the stock market when you know that they tend to focus on cryptocurrency. Though the case count in the state remained low during the summer and fall, it began to trend upward by late December, when Dr. Malone spoke with Mr. Rogan, and reached more than 11,000 daily cases in mid-January. Hundreds of public health officials and professors, citing the promotion of several falsehoods about Covid-19 vaccines, urged the service to crack down on misinformation about the virus. The catalyst for much of the controversy was a December episode of his podcast that featured Dr. Robert Malone, a virologist and vaccine skeptic. By the way, can I have a promotion? Its not clear whether mass formation psychosis has been an established scientific term or is a new/recent amalgamation of two existing terms. He's a member of the rap group Cypress Hill, host of several podcasts, including "Dr. Greenthumb" and "The Smokebox," and founder of Dr. Greenthumbs and Insane Cannabis, Phuncky Feel Tips, and Insane Clothing. He also spoke about the dangers of. Brian Redban is a comedian, producer, and founder of the Deathsquad podcast network. The overwhelming evidence is the vaccine works, and it is safe., Related Stories March 1, 2023. Copyright 2023 Penske Business Media, LLC. When she watched the interview, she was horrified to see that heespoused various conspiratorial and baseless beliefs, from the idea that mass formation psychosis is responsible for people believing in the efficacy of vaccines; to the claim popular among anti-vaxxers that hospitals are financially incentivized to falsely diagnose Covid-19 deaths. For one thing, it's a fragmented medium. The chief executive of Spotify responded on Sunday to growing complaints from musicians and listeners over the role of Joe Rogan, the streaming service's star podcaster, in . Photo of electric charging station powered by diesel generator is emblematic of the electric vehicle movement. Joseph James Rogan (born August 11, 1967) is an American UFC color commentator, podcaster, comedian, actor, and former television presenter. Then this thing happened, and everyone focused on it, stated Malone without specifying what exactly this thing or it was. Today, I entered the transcript of the Joe Rogan Experience #1757 into the Congressional Record to preserve the podcast forever. Heres a fact check of some of their claims. According to Bartletts article, you might very well walk away with the skewed sense, after hearing Malone speak or reading his posts, that there is a far-reaching Covid-19 cover-up and that the real threat is the vaccine rather than the virus.. Dark novel 'Anthem' from Austin author Noah Hawley reckons with twilight's last gleaming, Rogan announcedhe had contracted COVID-19, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Video of Spotify host Joe Rogans controversial interview with a doctor known for making false claims about the COVID-19 vaccines was removed from YouTube, just days after Twitter banned the doctors account for violating its COVID-19 misinformation policies. Says an image shows the Highland Park shooting suspect "in jail or rehab or a psychiatric center" before the shooting. No credit card needed. Look for book 12 in the series, "Burner," on February 21, 2023. www.markgreaneybooks.com, BridgetPhetasyis a writerandstand-up comedian. The 100 Greatest TV Shows of All Time ! He bills himself as the "inventor" of mRNA vaccines and has leveraged that title to push one false claim after another. - Listen to #1757 - Dr. Robert Malone, MD by The Joe Rogan Experience instantly on your tablet, phone or browser - no downloads needed. Joe Rogan, seen here during a UFC event, recently, interviewed Robert Malone, MD, who used the term "mass formation psychosis" to describe what's been happening in the U.S. in recent years. An earlier version of this story had the year wrong. Stoking fears and division can certainly further promote mass formation whatever-you-want-to-call-it. And one way to do that is to evoke images of Nazi Germany when everyone instead should really be focused on fighting against the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) that has already killed over 800,000 Americans. Those surrounding states in the Palestinian territory does not have that level of vaccine uptake at all. Twitters move to deplatform Dr. Malone and remove the interview from their site is the latest in a string of censuring individuals who dissent against the COVID-19 vaccine and vaccine mandates. Its a bit outrageous to suggest that people are maintaining Covid-19 precautions such as getting vaccinated and wearing face masks simply because of some type of psychosis. The reality is that the SARS-CoV-2 has been killing people and leaving many with persistent problems. On December 31, Rogan's Spotify podcast "The Joe Rogan Experience", which reaches 11 million people per episode, featured an interview with Dr Robert Malone. Austin concerts postponed or canceled as omicron surges: Erasure, Best Coast, and more. In a way, perhaps some. The currently available mRNA vaccines are the results of contributions from multiple people in different locations over time. In addition to appearing with Rogan, who has made and played host to several inaccurate claims about the COVID-19 vaccines, Malone has given interviews to Fox News host Tucker Carlson, InfoWars reporter Kristi Leigh, and former Trump adviser Steve Bannon all of whom have captured audiences while spreading misinformation about the vaccines. Available now on @spotify Dr. Robert Malone is the inventor of the nine original mRNA vaccine patents, which were . These are preventable illnesses that folks like Joe Rogan and Dr. Robert Malone are directly responsible for.. The letter goes on to list what the medical experts say are additional instances of COVID-19 falsehoods promoted on the podcast. podcast with Sal Vulcano. "We're not talking about fringe ideas," she said. Dr. Robert Malone was banned from Twitter for violating the platform's COVID-19 misinformation policies. A Massachusetts psychosis? "You can take the first step in the technology, but that doesn't mean that you invented the technology. Malone then described how leaders can exploit this situation: And one of the aspects of that phenomenon is that the people that they identify as their leaders, the ones typically that come in and say you have this pain and I can solve it for you. They completely disregard bioethics, they completely disregard the federal common rule, they have broken all the rules that I know of that I've been trained on for years and years, these mandates of an experimental vaccine are explicitly illegal. In the words of Neo in The Matrix, whoa. Dr. Robert Malone is the inventor of the nine original mRNA vaccine patents, which were originally filed in 1989 (including both the idea of mRNA vaccines and the original proof of principle experiments) and RNA transfection. He wondered aloud whether the vaccine President Joe Biden took on live TV was "really a vaccine." But back to 2021 and Malones interview. Joe Rogan is currently one of the most popular personalities in the world of MMA and UFC, largely thanks to his commentary skills and also his podcast. The overwhelming evidence is that the vaccines are safe and that they're effective.". If you remember back before 2019 everyone was complaining, the world doesnt make sense and we are all isolated from each other.. As a high-level scientist, hes been involved in the response to every major outbreak since AIDS. Rifles were involved in 297 deaths in the U.S. in 2022 and constipation killed 2,167.. Doctors are calling on Spotify to crack down on misinformation on its platform after the UFC commentator Joe Rogan's highly influential podcast featured a controversial interview with Dr. Robert Malone. The Justice Department has been calling parents that are concerned about what their kids are being taught, they are labeling them terrorists., Sen. Marco Rubio signed a 2021 letter that supports waivers that would reduce visual track inspections.. He also offers insight into the modern propaganda machine that has corrupted the scientific community.Sponsors:The Ministry of Pre-Born and Blaze Media are partnering up to help rescue babies from abortion in 2022. eople who dont have the scientific or medical background to recognize the things hes saying are not true and are unable to distinguish fact from fiction are going to believe what [Malone is] saying, and this is the biggest podcast in the world. Speaking of the U.S., Malone next connected all of this with America, asserting that We had all those conditions. http://www.youtube.com/@breakingpoints, Kyle Kulinski is a political activist and commentator. So why haven't podcasts gotten the same kind of attention as social networks? But they want the company to be more transparent about its rules, do more to moderate misinformation and make it easier to flag these kinds of baseless claims. But on this episode of "The Glenn Beck Podcast," Glenn challenges you, his audience, to ask Dr. Malone anything censorship-free. Twitter's move to deplatform Dr. Malone and remove the interview from their site is the latest in a string of censuring individuals who dissent against the COVID-19 vaccine and vaccine mandates. "Wherever you have users generating content, you're going to have all of the same content moderation issues and controversies that you have in any other space," said Evelyn Douek, a research fellow at Columbia University's Knight First Amendment Institute. In 1998, Andrew Wakefield, a physician later stripped of his medical license, falsified research that wrongly claimed a link between the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine and autism. He recovered from the . And so the extreme example, just to show the absurdity: If the patient comes in with a bullet hole in the head and they do a nose swab and they come up P.C.R. 1800 I Street NW www.shanemgillis.com Mark is the co-host of the podcasts "Tuesdays with Stories" with Joe List and "We Might Be Drunk" with Sam Morril. There have been calls for boycotts, and Mr. Rogan issued an apology for his past use of a racial slur and took down as many as 70 old episodes of his podcast, The Joe Rogan Experience, without explanation. An image shows a UFO photographed on June 21, 2014 by the pilot from the cockpit of an F-16 military plane flying near Lackland Air Force Base of the United States located in San Antonio, Texas., No one with a concealed carry permit ever committed a mass shooting. What was it exactly? We have an infodemic going on that, is prolonging the pandemic and it is causing people to make bad choices and actually die. Richards gave Rein the idea of penning an open letter to Spotify when he approached her with his concerns over the Malone episode. For example, someones immediate cause of death could be respiratory distress syndrome, which was caused by viral pneumonia, which in turn was caused by the coronavirus. Joe Rogan welcomed Dr. Robert Malone on his podcast, The Joe Rogan Experience, . He's also the co-host, along with Brian Redban, of the podcast and live-streaming YouTube show "Kill Tony." The popular podcast host has been controversial for years, but criticism ramped up after a December 31 episode featuring physician and biochemist Dr. Robert Malone. Douglas P. DeFelice/Getty Images (Photo by: Michael Siluk/Education Images/Universal Images Group via Getty Images), Education Images/Universal Images Group via Getty Images, Americans are getting more miserable, and theres data to prove it, defined by the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) defines psychosis, The Vaccine Scientist Spreading Vaccine Misinformation, According to Claire Goforth described for. 727-821-9494, Who is Robert Malone? These mandates of an experimental vaccine are explicitly illegal. Some social media accounts have been asking people please share this far and wide with this being a video of Rogans interview of Malone: Gee, telling someone to share a video far and wide could work really well among people afflicted with what kind of condition again? And if you look at some of the outrageous, unscientific things that are said on social media in general, it typically takes a fair amount of pseudosciencing to get booted in this manner. These are fringe ideas not backed in science, and having it on a huge platform makes it seem there are two sides to this issue. Though a spokesperson for Twitter did not say which of Malones tweets were in violation of the platforms policies, archives of Malones page show it was littered with vaccine skepticism. Several prominent musicians and podcasters have left Spotify to protest what they described as Joe Rogans history of promoting misinformation about the coronavirus and vaccines. Dr. Robert Malone, who gained hundreds of thousands of Twitter followers in recent months as he promoted anti-vaccine falsehoods, drew a comparison in the interview between COVID-19 vaccination efforts in the U.S. and the environment in Germany in the 1920s and 1930s, when the Nazi party rose to power. Concerned about being deplatformed, Rogan created an account on Gettr, a pro-Trump alternative social media platform, and told his followers to join him there. When alerted to the error, the authors withdrew the paper and apologized for their mistake. Dr. Robert Malone talks on his phone as he works from a home office in Madison, Va., on July 22, 2020. Were not the best, but were definitely not the worst.. The recommendations, from [], WASHINGTON, D.C. Congressman Troy E. Nehls (R-TX-22), Chairman of the Subcommittee on Railroads, Pipelines, and Hazardous Materials for the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, released a statement following his visit to the Norfolk Southern train derailment site in East Palestine, Ohio: I visited East Palestine, Ohio, yesterday to meet with local leaders and [], WASHINGTON, D.C. Congressman Troy E. Nehls (R-TX-22) released a statement following the State of the Union address given by President Joe Biden: Tonight, we heard embellished statements from a President who does not live in Real America, said Congressman Nehls. All those other steps had to occur. He said hospitals are so financially incentivized to claim COVID-19 as the cause of patient deaths that a hypothetical patient "with a bullet hole to the head" would be ruled as a COVID-19 fatality if they tested positive. https://www.youtube.com/@WOLFEUNTAMED95, Russell Brand is a comedian, actor, author, activist, and host of the podcast "Stay Free with Russell Brand." Two years after the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a global pandemic, Glenn sits down with one of the biggest victims of the other pandemic it ushered in: censorship. Thats False. Tony Hinchcliffe is a stand-up comedian, writer, and actor. Malone contributed to important early research. "On the one hand, he argues, Im the inventor of this technology. On the other hand, he's telling you that the technology is doing an enormous amount of harm," Offit said. You probably havent told your significant other, your cooking is a product of mass formation psychosis or your boss you are the product of mass formation psychosis. episode featuring COVID-19 vaccine skeptic Dr. Robert Malone, according . Actor Tom Holland is confirmed to have died.. A group of 270 doctors, science teachers, and physicians have co-signed a letter asking for Joe Rogan's podcast The Joe Rogan Experience to be disciplined for allegedly promoting Covid . Last year, Spotify CEO Daniel Ek told Axios that the company does not take responsibility for what Rogan or his guests say. Now, were two years into this and Sweden doesnt really stand out, Anders Tegnell, the countrys chief epidemiologist, told The Financial Times in November. Considering their role in society is disseminating content, there is a responsibility in a global public health emergency to not exacerbate the problem, she says. This is what really bothers me, she tellsRolling Stone. Hmm, by can be led anywhere, did Malone mean like believing conspiracy theories such as those claiming that Covid-19 vaccines can make keys stick to your forehead or have other side effects that arent being revealed? Theyve been shared by the likes of Seb Gorka, a radio host and former Trump adviser, and Dr. Simone Gold, the founder of Americas Frontline Doctors, a group that has fought restrictions to curb the virus spread. Malone went on Fox News host Laura Ingrahams primetime TV show Jan. 3 to react to what he framed as an attempt to "suppress" him. The release date of the show is yet to be known. Any podcast that platforms dangerous people, people spreading dangerous ideas and misinformation, should not be allowed to go unchecked on the Spotify platform, says Abbie Richards, a researcher specializing in misinformation. Douek says it's also harder to ferret out falsehoods and hate speech in podcasts compared with posts written on Facebook and Twitter. As an infectious disease epidemiologist and research fellow at Bostons Childrens Hospital who debunks health misinformation on Instagram where she has more than 380,000 followers Jessica Malaty Rivera regularly receives tips from her followers about viral content to debunk. Throughout the pandemic, some social media users have misinterpreted data from the C.D.C. "Like all people, scientists can be flawed, can make mistakes, can be misguided, and can even spread misinformation on purpose," said Yotam Ophir, an assistant professor of communication at the University of Buffalo who has researched misinformation in health, science and politics. Other fact-checkers debunked his related claim in another video that the spike proteins often cause irreparable damage to childrens vital organs. Soon after, YouTube removed videos of a controversial interview he did with Spotify podcast host Joe Rogan, according to reports. On episode 1757 which aired on Dec. 31, Rogan invited virologist and self-proclaimed "inventor of mRNA", as per his LinkedIn bio, Dr. Robert Malone on his show The Joe Rogan Experience (JRE . False. He writes and publishes TK News at taibbi.substack.com andhosts the "America This Week podcast with Walter Kirn." Spotify airs the popular podcast "The Joe Rogan Experience," where last month the comedian interviewed Dr. Robert Malone, an infectious disease specialist who has become a hero in the anti . Joe Rogans guest was a vaccine scientist, became an anti-vaccine darling. But more recently, he's been permanently suspended from Twitter and banned from LinkedIn. She has studied how the "Big Lie" that the 2020 presidential election was stolen from Donald Trump spread on political podcasts in the lead-up to the insurrection at the U.S. Capitol. And there are really not. Copyright 2023 Apple Inc. All rights reserved. Dr. Malone walks Glenn through all the complicated science behind mRNA vaccines, where he believes COVID-19 came from, and what he believes should have been done differently over the past two years. For example, there were tweets such as the following: Apparently, this social media account thinks that mass formation psychosis means making everyone look like Gamora from Guardians of the Galaxy or a character from the movie Avatar. A few weeks ago, her followers started sending her a link to an episode of the Joe Rogan Experience, the most popular podcast in the world. Unlike many platforms, Spotify doesn't have a clear policy prohibiting misinformation. The Joe Rogan Experience on Spotify, "#1757 - Dr. Robert Malone, MD," Dec. 31, 2021, Robert Malone on Twitter (archived), accessed Jan. 5, 2022, Robert Malones website, accessed Jan. 5, 2022, Fox News, "Dr. Robert Malone on Joe Rogan interview censorship, Twitter ban: 'You can't suppress information,'" Jan. 4, 2022, Fox News, "The Ingraham Angle," Jan. 3, 2022, Congressman Troy Nehls, "Joe Rogan Experience #1757 Dr. Robert Malone, MD Full Transcript," Jan. 3, 2022, The Independent, "YouTube takes down antivaxx Joe Rogan interview with Dr Robert Malone which likened vaccines to mass psychosis," Jan. 3, 2022, InfoWars, "Great Reset Exposed By Dr. Robert Malone In Powerful Infowars Interview," Jan. 1, 2022, USA Today, "Uncounted: Inaccurate death certificates across the country hide the true toll of COVID-19," Dec. 26, 2021, AFP Fact Check, "Video makes inaccurate claims about Covid-19 shots harming children," Dec. 23, 2021, AAP Fact Check, "Child vaccination video fails screen test for truth," Dec. 23, 2021, Health Feedback, "The benefits of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines for children outweigh the low risks, unlike what Robert Malone claimed," Dec. 20, 2021, Media Matters for America, "Hannity continues radio campaign to undermine COVID-19 vaccines, hosts guest who claims unvaccinated Americans 'are at risk from the vaccinated,'" Sept. 24, 2021, Nature, "The tangled history of mRNA vaccines," Sept. 14, 2021, FactCheck.org, "Researcher Distorts Facts on COVID-19 Vaccine Approval, Liability," Aug. 30, 2021, Health Feedback, "The development of mRNA vaccines was a collaborative effort; Robert Malone contributed to their development, but he is not their inventor," Aug. 26, 2021, The Atlantic, "The Vaccine Scientist Spreading Vaccine Misinformation," Aug. 12, 2021, Health Feedback, "COVID-19 vaccines effectively prevent severe disease; havent shown signs of antibody-dependent enhancement as claimed by Robert Malone," July 31, 2021, AFP Fact Check, "Flawed study misrepresents Covid-19 vaccination fatality rate," July 13, 2021, Logically, "Dr. Robert Malone invented mRNA vaccines," July 8, 2021, Fox News, "mRNA vaccine inventor speaks out on 'Tucker' after YouTube deletes video of him discussing risks," June 23, 2021, Stat News, "The story of mRNA: How a once-dismissed idea became a leading technology in the Covid vaccine race," Nov. 10, 2020, Science, "Direct Gene Transfer into Mouse Muscle in Vivo," March 23, 1990, PNAS, "Cationic liposome-mediated RNA transfection," May 12, 1989, PolitiFact, "Claim about omicron risk for the vaccinated is missing key context," Jan. 4, 2022, PolitiFact, "No scientific basis for claims of ivermectins success in Uttar Pradesh, India," Nov. 12, 2021, PolitiFact, "COVID-19 death rate in England much higher among unvaccinated than vaccinated," Oct. 29, 2021, PolitiFact, "Key threat to unvaccinated people is other unvaccinated people," Oct. 27, 2021, PolitiFact, "No, White House didnt create fake set just for Joe Bidens booster shot," Sept. 30, 2021, PolitiFact, "Licensed doctors who spread COVID-19 disinformation face no consequences, report shows," Sept. 22, 2021, PolitiFact, "Joe Rogan falsely says mRNA vaccines are gene therapy,'" Aug. 31, 2021, PolitiFact, "Heres why experts say people who had COVID-19 should be vaccinated," July 27, 2021, PolitiFact, "Journal discredits study it published claiming a COVID-19 vaccine causes deaths," July 2, 2021, PolitiFact, "No sign that the COVID-19 vaccines spike protein is toxic or cytotoxic,'" June 16, 2021, PolitiFact, "Tucker Carlsons misleading claim about deaths after COVID-19 vaccine," May 6, 2021, PolitiFact, "Federal VAERS database is a critical tool for researchers, but a breeding ground for misinformation,' May 3, 2021, PolitiFact, "Youth is not invincible: 9 experts dispute Joe Rogans vaccine advice for healthy 21-year-olds," April 28, 2021, PolitiFact, "How COVID-19 death counts become the stuff of conspiracy theories," Nov. 2, 2020, PolitiFact, "Donald Trumps false claim that doctors inflate COVID-19 deaths to make more money," Nov. 1, 2020, PolitiFact, "Fact-check: Hospitals and COVID-19 payments," April 21, 2020, PolitiFact, "5 facts about vaccines," Nov. 1, 2019, Phone interview with Dr. Davidson Hamer, professor of global health and medicine at Boston University School of Public Health and School of Medicine, Jan. 5, 2022, Phone interview with Dr. Paul Offit, director of the Vaccine Education Center at the Childrens Hospital of Philadelphia and chair of vaccinology at the University of Pennsylvanias Perelman School of Medicine, Jan. 5, 2022, Email interview with Yotam Ophir, assistant professor of communication at Buffalo University, Jan. 5, 2022, Email correspondence with Twitter, Jan. 4, 2022, District of Columbia